Here Comes the P2P Economy

< Previous | Main | Next >

2nd Oct 2008




Article Image
Stan Stalnaker in HBR Feb. 2008


Tuesday, 6 May 2008


This year the Harvard Business Review created their list of the year's top 20 Breakthrough Ideas and features as one of them a Hub Culture concept around P2P finance, tied to the development of Ven, Hub's social currency available inside Facebook, on this site and soon at our Pavilions:

"Peer-to-peer, or P2P, networks have thrown the media industry into turmoil, changing the flow of information from a one-to-many model (with newspaper publishers, Hollywood studios, and big music companies as the sources) to a many-to-many model (with blogs, YouTube, and file-sharing forums as the venues). The ability of individuals to both consume and create content—news, movies, and music—greatly threatens traditional players. Witness the struggles of established U.S. newspaper publishers—the share prices of the four largest have fallen between 10% and 50% during the generally rising market of the past three years—because of challenges from new media and advertising models, including P2P schemes.

A shock like the one that jolted the media is poised to strike other industries, perhaps more disruptively. It is already being felt in financial services. Start with the phenomenon of microcredit: the lending of small sums to, and then within, social groups at the village level in poor economies, with members collectively guaranteeing the bank's loan. Combine that with the power of a global digital network, and a new model for banking begins to take shape.

Indeed, P2P financial systems are set to reprise in the banking industry what has happened in media. Already, websites like Kiva, Prosper, and LendingClub have extended microbanking to consumers in developed economies. In such systems, everyone is a tiny bank, making it easier to raise small amounts of capital among people who know—or at least, because of their social network, trust—one another. Research by TIME magazine shows that early default rates on these types of 'social loans' are many times lower than those enjoyed by traditional banks.

Article Image
New media P2P schemes challenge hard currency
It is only a matter of time before these digital systems close the arbitrage enjoyed by large banks, which lend at up to 15% interest but pay only about 5% on capital. Why do business with a bank when your network's lending and savings interest rates are both 7%? To grasp the power of such a system, imagine your local credit union with the membership and social networking capabilities of MySpace.

Furthermore, people will soon use personal currencies to make payments for "knowledge services" provided by other individuals, such as social introductions and shopping tips. These currencies will be traded on exchanges at floating rates determined by the market in real time. Like national currencies, personal currencies derive their value from the reputation and size of the network—status as an expert and number of friends, in this case, rather than market expectations and size of the economy.

An even greater shock could hit the energy industry, transforming it into a network that would make the current electricity grid seem rudimentary. Again, the consumer-producer would be the driving force. Some people are already installing home-based solar or other energy sources that allow them to sell electricity to the grid. Companies are using the roofs of their buildings for installations that turn the facilities into net power producers. Energy production and distribution could ultimately shift from a few key players to many participants.

Article Image
BMW Active Hybrid 2008
"The real breakthrough will come when cars generate more electricity than they consume—not as outlandish as it sounds. Hybrid vehicles currently take the kinetic electricity generated by braking and use it to help fuel motion and prolong battery life. BMW is the acknowledged leader in research into these technologies, with recent announcements about advancements in this area. Eventually, kinetic and battery technologies could improve to the point where cars generate excess kinetic power from their motion to be stored and sold back to the grid for micropayments."

The result of these P2P changes could be a system of consumer-producers, where we account more fully for the product cycles of information, finance and energy - producing a more efficient and robust economy as we do so.